Close
Close

Do Search Engines Love Opinion Posts As Much As We Do?

This guest post is by Helen Hoefele of Figmentations.com.

Is the goal of your blogging efforts is to make money, to raise money, to sell or promote a product or service, or simply to get your message out?

Regardless, the one thing that every blogger needs to pay attention to, whether you’re excited about it or not, is the importance of creating high quality content to keep both your readers and the search engines happy.

We all know that Google has been favoring sites with high quality content over sites with low quality content. Sites consisting of low quality or duplicate content and/or employing manipulative SEO practices in order to unfairly influence site rankings have lost ground in their search engine ranking results.

What many people may not realize is that “not creating low quality content” does not necessarily mean you are creating high quality content.

So let’s take a closer look at what high quality content, and ultimately high value content, can mean. In particular, let’s consider where opinion-editorial (op-ed) writing falls on the quality scale.

At face value, because op-eds are generally subjective rather than objective in nature, it may not be clear whether or not they count as high quality content for blog SEO purposes.

For SEO-quality-related questions like this, I would recommend asking yourself this question, as per SearchEngineLand.com, about the writing you want to publish: “Do you offer real value, something of substance to visitors, anything unique, different, useful and that they won’t find elsewhere?” If your material meets those criteria, and of course you avoid any questionable SEO practices intended to manipulate rankings, it should be clear that you do not have low quality content.

As most industry observers state, if you write for readers and not for search engines, you should be fine. So, yes, opinions can be considered high quality content for SEO purposes.

However, we shouldn’t stop there; there are more questions to ask. When deciding whether or not to express your opinions in your writing, the better question to ask is: Is there value in expressing opinions beyond just SEO value? A simple answer of “yes” does not suffice here. For that, let’s take a closer look at value.

Low value

In any given blog post, if a reader disagrees with your opinion, especially if it’s unexpected to you, there is value for you to delve into understanding why.

More likely, though, any discussion starting from a place of vehement disagreement is more than likely to devolve into an endless circular debate resulting in anger or frustration on both sides with no common understanding or resolution ever achieved. There is not much value in alienating readers, unless your goal is to filter out unwelcome readers from your audience or perhaps, if skillfully done, evolve your tribe from becoming too much of an echo chamber.

Superficial value

Even if you could write an opinion piece with a catchy title that ends up ranking high and gets a lot of social mentions, that doesn’t automatically mean you have created high quality content. And even if that piece were to go viral, that does not guarantee conversion, as is being shown time and time again.

Anything that attracts attention but results in a high bounce rate and low time-on-site numbers is nothing more than wasted opportunity to provide true value to potentially interested readers.

Missed value

At the same time, high quality opinion pieces that do not rank high due to poor writing, poor search engine optimization, and/or poor after-publication social sharing will miss the mark, too. Good ideas, as with useful opinions, absolutely need to be paired with good SEO practices and effective social sharing in order to get the exposure they rightly deserve.

Practical value

On the other hand, you could ask: if your reader readily agrees with your expressed opinion, is anything of value accomplished in still stating that opinion?

Social media was used heavily in the recent U.S. Presidential election. Yet, it likely did little to actually sway any already-committed points of view. All that such social media outreach achieved was: reinforce the base; exert peer pressure; or generate social proof among friends, family, or acquaintances. While that did have a considerable impact on the get-out-to-vote initiatives, it did nothing to change anything about the world—it did not improve the electoral process, or unify the country, or solve any of the country’s much-debated problems.

Value-added value

In the end, getting good exposure for a specific opinion aimed at a targeted audience is not the only game in town. A quote from Chris Brogan and Julien Smith’s book (which has largely inspired this post), The Impact Equation, sums it up nicely:

“Your opinions may be helpful and interesting, but unless they are specifically useful to your audience, you are not building something of significant or lasting value.”

Opinions about another person’s ideas become especially valuable when they help evolve and spread that idea to others who will keep it alive and do something with it.

Bottom line

In the end, while Google might not be able to distinguish between these different value levels (yet), your readers can. Remember, you are writing for your readers and not for the search engines.

Each person’s blog and reason for blogging is different. What works for you and your audience may or may not work for someone else’s. Many times you won’t even know what will or won’t work until you test it out. Always experiment. Don’t fear making any potential minor miss-steps, as you will find that most audiences are quite forgiving.

Why not test each of these value theories out with your own blog over the next few weeks? Try these tests:

  • Write a rant: After sleeping on it and making sure it isn’t unnecessarily offensive or regretful, consider posting it to see how your readers react in comments, shares, and subscription levels. Do they engage or do they leave?
  • Write something generic about a trending topic found on SocialMention. Take some time to formulate a catchy title. Share on social sites as you normally would. Then check your stats to compare your bounce rates and time-on-site metrics for that post with a popular but more thought-provoking post from your site.
  • Choose a popular blog post, either yours or someone else’s. Promote it on your favorite social sharing sites but experiment with different social media messages accompanying that link, with some messages well written and others less well written. Observe the importance of effective messaging as seen in the number of shares and re-tweets.
  • Write an opinion piece that you know everyone will agree with, then ask for comments and feedback. Compare the quality and emotion level generated by the generic opinion post versus an original thought-provoking opinion post or even comments against the rant piece mentioned in the first point above.
  • Take some time and formulate a useful opinion piece or blog comment—not something that’s an off-the-cuff reaction, but a unique, thoughtful response, perhaps taking into account comments or opinions that others already left on that post or topic. Assess the quality of feedback you receive.

Expressing unique opinions has value and should easily count as high quality content for SEO purposes. Never forget that opinion writing can provide a lot more than just SEO value, too.

In the end, writing a useful and thought-provoking post is not only more interesting for your readers to read, but more interesting for you to write as well. Why not put the power of the keyboard to work for you?

In her spare time, Helen Hoefele shares her thoughts and opinions via her personal blog at Figmentations.com. By day, she is a productive member on the Inbound Marketing team at a NJ-based SEO services company.

About Guest Blogger

This post was written by a guest contributor. Please see their details in the post above. If you'd like to guest post for ProBlogger check out our Write for ProBlogger page for details about how YOU can share your tips with our community.

Problogger.net runs on the Genesis Framework

Genesis Framework

The Genesis Framework empowers you to quickly and easily build incredible websites with WordPress. Genesis provides the secure and search-engine-optimized foundation that takes WordPress to places you never thought it could go.

Check out the incredible features and the selection of designs. It's that simple - start using Genesis now!

Comments

  1. Thanks for the tips. I am going to try some of this on my next series of blog posts. Keep these articles coming!!

    I honestly think that teh search engines follow people. If we write for people, search will find us anyhow. After all, search is all about providing to the people anyhow!

    • “Providing to the people” is exactly right. What we provide to them is as important as how.

    • Agreed with your words John, I’ve seen that bloggers and marketers always tried to follow search engines and to learn the new skills to get high ranking, but search engines does the same. They follow us and If our readers are enjoying the content, they gives us the rank.

    • Rank Watch says:

      Great post. There is a myth in the industry that the all posts which gets lot of social shares across different social platforms and all the posts which is on an authoritative site are all of high quality and credibility which is not rightly so all the time. Thanks for trying to bust this myth to a decent extent in this blog.

      • Actually, you are quite right. That is definitely a point that could have been brought out more. Lately, I have also become much more aware that even blogspot sites, those that do not yet even have their own domain names, that some have very engaged and active audiences, more so than some high ranking domains.

        Not only would it be inaccurate to over-value a site or post solely based on SEO rank and number of social shares, but it would be an equally big mistake to disregard the value of any site that ranks low in those areas. I believe any site/post, regardless of SEO rank, has the potential to make an impact and/or go viral under the right combination of ingredients. Great point!

  2. rahul says:

    great tips buddy now am gonna apply these tips in my fure of blogging
    thanx a lot for sharing this information with us
    happy blogging

  3. Rahul says:

    this is new tips i have listen first time about this very beneficial for my blog thanks for sharing…

  4. mohit says:

    oh…now I was doing that wrong and was not knowing that also,but yes thanks for the help and yes great tips,it will help me and other bloggers too.

  5. Matt Brennan says:

    The search engines are getting smarter. As Google places a larger value on social, I would imagine that will help the state of opinion blogs. Good post, with good info to consider!

    • True. I used to underestimate how smart these search engines were capable of being, but the more I read and learn about current and future trends in that space, the more I’m starting to believe we will be seeing bigger and quicker changes in how they work sooner rather than later. I don’t know if Big Data will make those changes more difficult or more imminent, but it will be an interesting landscape to experience.

  6. Eric says:

    I always enjoy a good rant post its so much fun! I think you should just be yourself, write how you want, and continue to be yourself.

    Your never going to be able to please everyone, but as long as your playing fair and offering real value Google will let you be.

    • Yes, if done right, rant posts that hit a nerve can be quite effective in triggering reactions. Reactions leading to actions and involvement is definitely preferred over complacency, right? Pleasing everyone is boring in comparison. And, I agree with what you said about “playing fair” and “offering real value”. That’s definitely what the readers want and something that I believe the search engines will be getting better at sorting through, too.

  7. Tayyab Nasir says:

    This is true blogging takes time but we should also do our full efforts to compete with others.

  8. Yes it actually helps and search engines actually love when people share your articles. Opinion is what connects people and when people react to it, search engine comes running to your blog. Great way to get attention!