Close
Close

Blogs Are About Being Elite

There is nothing like a good controversy, and have I got controversy for you today. Since this is the first guest post while Darren is gone, it seems appropriate to make things necessarily volatile right from the start.

The subject today is elitism and its place in blogging. You see, it all began over on my blog with an entry observing that Technorati had begun indexing MySpace blogs.

I was Rubel-bombed which brought another breed of commenters to this topic. My argument was that by Technorati indexing MySpace blogs, the quality of Technorati results would be diminished. One commenter responded that the internet is not for elitists.

As a matter of fact, when content production is at play, the internet IS for elitists. Perhaps we don’t like to use those words as “elitism” has a negative stigma to it. However, don’t we all try to get higher pagerank? Don’t we all try to optimize our entries for the best SERPs possible? Doesn’t scoring high in Technorati bump our profile up in general?

In other words, it’s a good thing to be in the elite and it’s highly unfair to those of us who work hard to position our blogs in strategically excellent positioning to have the pool of content thinned by less than excellent content.

What are your thoughts?

Problogger.net runs on the Genesis Framework

Genesis Framework

The Genesis Framework empowers you to quickly and easily build incredible websites with WordPress. Genesis provides the secure and search-engine-optimized foundation that takes WordPress to places you never thought it could go.

Check out the incredible features and the selection of designs. It's that simple - start using Genesis now!

Comments

  1. Leon says:

    I like elitism. It encourages quality. It’s either you become elite or get left behind. MSN Spaces blogs may pose a threat, but not Myspace blogs. It’s just a bunch of teens babbling among themselves about their crappy little lives.

  2. Max Edmands says:

    Hey, abd, why do you hate myspace so much? I mean, sure, it’s got crappy design, and every time you load a page there’s a billion advertisements, pop-up ads, and javascript errors, but it’s one of the most popular web sites out there to date… think of how many people it’s bringing online– people who now have the ability to read YOUR “tips for men” blog! (If they thought it had any value to them, that is.)

    And who knows? There are still some decent geocities pages out there today, and maybe some people will come up with something worthwhile on a myspace blog!

    Cutting off the large portion of the younger generation, those who rely on myspace like they rely on air, is a bad idea. And, really, how would technorati indexing myspace blogs affect you negatively, if at all?

  3. mp3 blog says:

    Those who can produce good content are an elite. It takes hard work, time, dedication, talent, luck and a bit of obsession to be a good blogger.

  4. Max Edmands says:

    Right. And who cares if that good content is on myspace or on a wordpress blog somewhere out there?

  5. Totally disagree. I don’t

  6. Maurice says:

    Hi

    Hmm don’t forget that PR is a zero sum game ;-)

    In away having lots of new low level myspace blogs coming into the index makes your high pr page worth relativly more.

    Rgds Maurice

    ps i realy must learn more about game theory

  7. I believe everyone that blogs deserves a chance to be seen. Just not anywhere above my blog on any serious blog engine. Also excluding people who cannot write. Or people who pass notes in class like “Do you like Bobby? ___Yes ___No ___Maybe”

    Also people who like dogs, hate cats, hate dogs, like cats, have opinions that contradict my own, and people who use “Dude” as a verb.

    Strike politicians and zealots while we’re at it.

    Other than that, I am 100% in favor of equal access. As long as that access does not infringe upon my turf. I am not an elitist by choice – it’s just that there are so few people in the world who have anything to say that I care to listen to.

    :)

Trackbacks

  1. Rubel Bombing vs. MySpace

    Aaron Brazell from the tech and politics blog, Technosailor, is guest blogging over at one of ThePublishingSpot’s favorite blogs, ProBlogger.  Turns out he generated a flurry of comments when he wrote this post:"[I]t all began over on my blo…

  2. [...] It’s that that blogs are about being elite and all that. It’s about making sense of all the noises out there. Will Technorati’s authority slider become more important because of this? Maybe that’s the reason they rolled it out before adding MySpace. [...]

  3. Myspace helps school expel Student

    A 16 year old student was expelled from Wilson High school in western New York for allegedly threatening to burn down his principal’s house in a message he had posted on Myspace. He will remain suspended for the rest of the year. More than 135 st…

  4. [...] It’s the controversy of the moment and I’ve stoked the fire at ProBlogger where I make the point that blogging is about being elite. [...]

  5. [...] Blogs Are About Being EliteBlogs Are About Being Elite You see, it all began over on my blog with an entry Music Phone Reviews | Digital Camera Shop | Digital Photography School | Best Digital [...]