I think it depends all on the stuff you like to have on the page.
not all stuff fits to the navigation sidebar. Maybe you need another one.

Just my 2 cents.

Like you mentioned, there is no such thing as THE solution. By no means was I attacking the discussion, just the fact that people were arguing over which is the best.

I’d be curious to hear the merits of each one, I personally use 3 columns, but that’s just cos’ it makes sense to me.

Ken: that’s exactly right – it depends. Because you have some expertise in your area, you know that the perfect camera depends upon its intended use. It’s a legitimate topic though, since many folks in this game don’t have that expertise (yet).

My post does go over in brief some of the factors invloved in choosing a layout, but it doesn’t go into too many specifics. I’ve told Darren I’d write a post for him while he’s away; I think you just found the topic for me! Thanks.

Instead of arguing what’s best, let’s argue the merits of each one and how and why it would work best in a certain situation.

It reminds me of cameras, everyone asks me who makes the best cameras, and the answer is ALWAYS, “it depends on what you are doing.”